Skip to content
Color — Ux — Poster — 3d — Layout — Ui — Creative — Art — Entertainment

Controversy Arises over AI Portrayal of Darth Vader in Fortnite Regarding Performer Remuneration

Epic Games faces an allegation from SAG-AFTRA due to their perceived mistreatment of actors' performances in Fortnite.

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
Epic Games accused by SAG-AFTRA for questionable labor practices.
Epic Games accused by SAG-AFTRA for questionable labor practices.

Controversy Arises over AI Portrayal of Darth Vader in Fortnite Regarding Performer Remuneration

Revised Star Wars AI Controversy:

Dive into the latest drama surrounding Star Wars and AI! First, the hype around Lucasfilm's innovative use of AI video gen in the Star Wars Field Report leaves fans questioning the future of VFX. Now, Fortnite is facing heat for their AI-voiced Darth Vader, causing quite a stir.

The Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) has lobbed a punch, accusing Epic Games' Llama Productions of bypassing human performers in favor of AI tech, all without giving a heads-up or negotiating the terms.

Didja notice the new Vader in town? Yep, guess who just landed at Solitude 👀 Tweet

The late, great James Earl Jones, who passed away last year at the ripe age of 93, had agreed to allow his recordings for future Lucasfilm projects. His family, though, permitted its use in Fortnite. Despite that, SAG-AFTRA claims that Fortnite's AI-generated Darth Vader voice wasn't given the green light by the union.

SAG-AFTRA says, "We champion the right of our members and their estates to control the use of their digital replicas. We welcome new technologies to let new generations savor those legacies and iconic roles. But we must protect our right to bargain terms and conditions for AI-generated voices that replace human actors' work."

This row isn't only about this particular case, but about the principles that govern AI voice replicas in light of ongoing game industry strikes.

Recent negotiations saw a final offer from developers, making some concessions. For instance, the option of one-time payment for unlimited pre-generated content in a game would be scrapped. This means that if actors agree to AI-generated digital replicas, they'd receive payments similar to those for original performances.

As of now, Epic Games, Fortnite's developers, hasn't responded to the complaint, making the industry wade through the complex ethical, legal, and professional quagmires lurking within AI game design.

Stay tuned for more AI news, like the Blender add-on that lets AI take charge!

Stand out from the crowd with Creative Bloq newsletter

Get daily design news, reviews, how-tos, and more, expertly picked by our editors.

:fire: Hot News: SAG-AFTRA has filed an unfair labor practice complaint against Epic Games' subsidiary, Llama Productions, for their use of AI-generated voice for Darth Vader in Fortnite. The controversy revolves around Epic Games employing AI technology instead of human voice actors without prior notification or negotiation[1][2][3].

:point_right: Union's Concerns:

  1. Fair Labor Practices: SAG-AFTRA advocates for fair labor practices in the face of new AI technologies. While they endorse innovation, they insist on safeguarding the rights of their union members[1][2].
  2. Notice and Bargaining: The complaint focuses on Epic Games' lack of communication and collaboration with SAG-AFTRA before implementing AI-generated voices[1][2].
  3. Protection of Union Work: SAG-AFTRA argues that union voice actors' previous work is now being carried out by AI. Rather than taking place through discussion, this change should have been agreed upon between the parties[2][3].

:point_right: Potential Implications:

  1. Setting AI Use Precedents: This case may establish a precedent for AI-generated voices in games. If upheld, it might lead to stricter regulations on using AI instead of human voice actors[2].
  2. Labor Relations and Negotiations: The outcome will shape future labor negotiations between game developers and unions, emphasizing the necessity of clear communication and agreement on AI technology use[1][2].
  3. Innovation and Labor Rights: The complaint underlines the challenge of balancing technological innovation with the protection of labor rights. Finding a harmony between these aspects is vital for the industry's evolution[1][3].
  4. The latest dispute in the entertainment industry revolves around the use of AI-generated voices in video games, as SAG-AFTRA has filed an unfair labor practice complaint against Epic Games' Llama Productions.
  5. SAG-AFTRA's concern lies in the fair labor practices, advocating for negotiations and safeguarding rights of its members as AI technology advances.
  6. The complaint highlights Epic Games' failure to provide notice and collaborate with SAG-AFTRA before incorporating AI-generated voices in their games.
  7. By replacement of human voice actors with AI technology, SAG-AFTRA argues that previous union work is being circumvented, a change that should have been discussed and agreed upon.
  8. The outcome of this controversy may set a precedent for AI use in games, potentially leading to stricter regulations and emphasizing the importance of clear communication in labor negotiations.
  9. Balancing technological innovation with labor rights is essential for the industry's future, as this case underlines the challenges that lie ahead in the realm of AI-driven creative design and entertainment.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest